BMW Luxury Touring Community banner

1 - 20 of 40 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
27 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Hello Friends.

Could anyone tell me if a stock BMW top case from a 1996 1100RT would be compatible with my 2010 R1200RT? I'm not sure how far back the mounting system on my bike goes back in the RT line. I know on many 3rd party cases the same case covers close to two decades of RTs, but wasn't sure about the original BMW cases. I'm looking at some used options from earlier years online but not sure if they fit. Anyone know of a reference chart that says what stock cases fit on what years?

As long as I'm on the subject, what are your favorite 3rd party top cases that would fit a 2010 RT? How many of your prefer NOT to use a top case on long trips and instead pack your bike across the luggage rack and rear seat with your own dry bags, etc.? That seems like it might be more efficient use of space. FYI, I'm a new BMW RT owner. In the past I loaded down my Suzuki SV650S with stuff. It wasn't pretty, but I made it work. My recent purchase of a used 2010 RT came without the top case. Buying a replacement from BMW is out of the question ($$$). Part of my debate about what to get revolves around whether I want the top case more for in town commuting and convenience (especially when my wife is along), in which case maybe I would not go for the largest one available, or whether I want the largest possible to be most useful when I take road trips.

I am not a person of unlimited funds, but I do want to get the right solution if I can afford it. The Shad 58l that adapts to two smaller sizes is pretty nice, but expensive - especially after you add in the back rest and brake light kit. A back rest is essential for use with a passenger (esp. my wife), and extra brake/running lights up high certainly seem like a good idea. I'm also looking at the GIVI cases currently.

Might anyone also tell me how much drag and/or turbulence is produced by some of these cases? I'm guessing there is some variation here by design as well as size, so any thoughts/experiences on that point would also be appreciated.

Thanks much!

North Woods Wanderer

2010 BMW R1200RT
2001 Suzuki SV650S
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
220 Posts
I just received the Givi V46 Monokey last Christmas, for my 2009 RT, and finally got it installed recently. Of course you have to get the compatible top case rack to mount it. I have the optional back rest pad for the wife, which you also have to install, and brake light. I modified it further to include additional brake lights and a blinking smart stop kit. But to answer your question, this was the best value for my money IMO. It holds two 3/4 helmets although one has to be turned sideways to fit. I have the original BMW 28 liter top case that looks decent but just didn't do it for me as far as available capacity, and the larger BMW case just cost too damn much for my older bike. I didn’t want a larger top case than the V46 as I thought it may look out of place. There are also weight limitations as with any top case. I haven’t done much traveling at distance or with it fully loaded so I can’t tell you if it will make the bike feel top heavy or not. I think it does look good though…….
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
27 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
I just received the Givi V46 Monokey last Christmas, for my 2009 RT, and finally got it installed recently. Of course you have to get the compatible top case rack to mount it. I have the optional back rest pad for the wife, which you also have to install, and brake light. I modified it further to include additional brake lights and a blinking smart stop kit. But to answer your question, this was the best value for my money IMO. It holds two 3/4 helmets although one has to be turned sideways to fit. I have the original BMW 28 liter top case that looks decent but just didn't do it for me as far as available capacity, and the larger BMW case just cost too damn much for my older bike. I didn’t want a larger top case than the V46 as I thought it may look out of place. There are also weight limitations as with any top case. I haven’t done much traveling at distance or with it fully loaded so I can’t tell you if it will make the bike feel top heavy or not. I think it does look good though…….
Thanks for that info ebiss9. I've looked at both the Givi Monokey and Monolock series cases, but haven't actually been able to examine any close up and in person. I agree that several of them look pretty good, including yours. I'm not sure if I want to go for a case that holds 2 full-face helmets or not. Kind of big but kind of a nice option to toss them in there. I wonder how much lighter weight the Monolock series is, as they are quite a bit cheaper.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,157 Posts
Could anyone tell me if a stock BMW top case from a 1996 1100RT would be compatible with my 2010 R1200RT?
No.
You wouldn't want it anyway. For such a large case it holds very little.



As for cases that do fit.

Most BMW cases from 2005 to 2019 RT's R's and RS's (and many K bikes),will fit (that is both the 28 liter and the large ones).


As for aftermarket cases, my current favourite are the variable size SHAD cases which expand vertically to allow you to stick more stuff in them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
I have a 2012 that came with the big BMW case. I think it is 41 liters. I hate the thing when riding solo it is like a sail you get pushed all over the road. It is nice if two up or a big dry bag behind the rider.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G891A using Tapatalk
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
436 Posts
Givi you need the key to open it every time (it cannot be left unlocked) which also introduces the joy of accidentally locking your keys in the case.

Look at the Shad cases. I recently bought a 39 liter case for my 2013 and it looks great and is of excellent quality. I have a detailed post over at the BMWMOA forum. I'd provide a link but I'm not sure linking to other forums is permitted here.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,157 Posts
I have a 2012 that came with the big BMW case. I think it is 41 liters. I hate the thing when riding solo it is like a sail you get pushed all over the road. It is nice if two up or a big dry bag behind the rider.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G891A using Tapatalk
Hi Zamram. I too dislike my large BMW case. Why? because it looks ugly! It has such wasted space inside with it's false bottom and carpet. However, as for it being like a sail and being blown around..I have NEVER experienced that (well, not caused by the top box anyway).

I too think the OP should take a peek at the Shad expandable boxes.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,691 Posts
A top case from 1996 BMW is too old to fit a 2010 RT. However, the pre-2014 top cases (see photo below) do. I moved one from my 2007 RT to my new RT without difficulty, just repainting the lid to match the RT.



They have another advantage -- the large top cases cost about half what the newer BMW top cases cost. The small cases are the same from 2005 through 2019.

I disagree with "Bandytales." I think BMW top cases look like the belong on BMWs. I have yet to see an aftermarket top case that looks that way.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
136 Posts
I ran a SHAD SH-48 on my FJR and was going to keep it when I decided to move on the the RT. But the used RT I ended up buying came with the factory topcase so I sold the SHAD. I had the optional backrest pad and my wife said it was fine for her on the FJR. It was good quality, held 2 medium full sized helmets, was quick and easy to remove, and looked pretty good. I ended up selling it.

I bought it brand new on Ebay from a dealer as an open box item and got it for around $150 shipped. Then the pad was additional. I did not add a light. As someone else mentioned you will need the SHAD adapter plate for the RT.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
471 Posts
I've put BMW's 28-liter case on my '06, '13, and '16 RTs. I painted their tops to match the bikes. It's well built but not heavy and is keyable to the bike, holds a helmet and more, looks great, makes a good passenger backrest, is not sensitive to side winds, and it doesn't block the rear view as the large case does. A box tail light isn't necessary to me since I always install supplemental LED tail/brake/turn lights.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
938 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
241 Posts
Hi Zamram. I too dislike my large BMW case. Why? because it looks ugly! It has such wasted space inside with it's false bottom and carpet. However, as for it being like a sail and being blown around..I have NEVER experienced that (well, not caused by the top box anyway).
I too think the OP should take a peek at the Shad expandable boxes.
The BMW 49L case that I have does not have carpeting and a false bottom (I know because I have taken it apart). And as far as it being a sail, try riding a K1300GT with a top case in a crosswind and not being two-up. Not a lot of fun! It did work better on my R1200RT.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
483 Posts
The BMW 49L case that I have does not have carpeting and a false bottom (I know because I have taken it apart). And as far as it being a sail, try riding a K1300GT with a top case in a crosswind and not being two-up. Not a lot of fun! It did work better on my R1200RT.
I did an errand today that required the top case (went to buy the BMW Venting Suit because we're getting some hot days now :smile:). It was windy through some of the more mountainous areas and I could definitely tell that the top case was on there. The sideways gusts had a greater impact on my line than normal.

That being said, its not horrible and the capacity of the box outweighs the wind profile IMO.

My RT with the 2005-2013 49L top box...
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
27 Posts
Discussion Starter #16
Have you considered CraigsList? Here is one in my local Orange Coast, CA edition that clearly needs paint, but IMHO they need to be color matched anyway ;-) Not saying this is a great deal, just using it as an example that they do come up every now and then.

https://orangecounty.craigslist.org/mpo/d/rancho-santa-margarita-bmw-top-case-and/6854044091.html
Thanks for that. Yes, I've been watching Craigslist, and also eBay, but haven't seen anything compelling in my area just yet. Have seen some used Givi top cases out there though.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
30 Posts
I hate the top case. For 2 reasons, I kick it every time I sling my leg over the saddle. I found the case was also very large outside for minimal storage inside.

I see you've looked at my pelican case setup, It's still my favorite top case option I can attach either the 1510, or the 1610. Very utilitarian but I've got no issue with that. Form before fashion.. The 1510 has a nice low profile so It's not a sail. The 1610 is more like a box van on the back..

When I need more "stuff" with the 1510, then I just ratchet strap my duffel bag on top of the pelican..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27 Posts
Discussion Starter #18
I hate the top case. For 2 reasons, I kick it every time I sling my leg over the saddle. I found the case was also very large outside for minimal storage inside.

I see you've looked at my pelican case setup, It's still my favorite top case option I can attach either the 1510, or the 1610. Very utilitarian but I've got no issue with that. Form before fashion.. The 1510 has a nice low profile so It's not a sail. The 1610 is more like a box van on the back..

When I need more "stuff" with the 1510, then I just ratchet strap my duffel bag on top of the pelican..
Hi Scurvy.

Yes, I did look at that Pelican setup. Looked pretty cool, although I'm not sure I'd be as adept as you in fashioning a system to attach the Pelican to. If I go the more utilitarian route I will maybe try your approach out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27 Posts
Discussion Starter #19
Well, I've ordered the Givi Monolock 450 and Monolock 470, as well as the Shad 58 expandable. I'm going to get my hands on them directly and compare. I can return any/all of them for free at Cycle Gear if I don't like them. I'll post an update after I have a closer look at them. In the meantime any other comments and recommendations are still welcome.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
220 Posts
Givi you need the key to open it every time (it cannot be left unlocked) which also introduces the joy of accidentally locking your keys in the case.
Although it does require a key to open the box latch every time, I tried to close the latch with the key out of the lock and could not. Unless things have changed recently with Givi locks, you can't accidently lock your key in it.

Well, I've ordered the Givi Monolock 450 and Monolock 470, as well as the Shad 58 expandable. I'm going to get my hands on them directly and compare. I can return any/all of them for free at Cycle Gear if I don't like them. I'll post an update after I have a closer look at them. In the meantime any other comments and recommendations are still welcome.
Whatever top box you decide to choose will be the right one I'm sure. I've finally completed the extra brake lights for my recent Givi V46 installation. I favored this unit with the optional brake light kit as it breaks the circuit when you open the lid or remove the box from the rack mount, no wiring to unhook although I've read that the connections are sometimes troublesome.......:confused:
 

Attachments

1 - 20 of 40 Posts
Top