BMW Luxury Touring Community banner

1 - 12 of 12 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,404 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
2000 K1200LT Icon all apart for 12K "BMW Inspection", top-end job, etc.
Decided to install a set of Speigler brake lines I've had for a year or more. I bough 'em a while back after reading a thread on this site about brake line failure.

Just one more of those things I didn't know I needed until I read about brake line failures on this site.
Here's a list of preemptive things I have done to the bike over the years 'cause posts on this forum prompted me: Replaced clutch slave cylinder, installed low beam HID, drilled bell housing weep hole, installed "fix it before it breaks" top case latch, and probably others I don't recall right now. (Oh, yeah, final drives) ;)
Those things in addition to the accessories I added like J-pegs, passenger floor boards and arm rests, cup holder, tank bag, Autocom... the list goes on. :histerica

So while I was changing out all my OEM brake lines (which were working just fine, thank you) I got to wondering why I was bothering to do it. I mean, these OEM lines looked good, and actually appeared robust compared to what I was installing in their place; I had no complaints regarding brake performance.

How many people have really had brake line failures on their K1200LT, I wondered. And how many reports of brake line failure were "fraudulent" reports by some person who job it is to increase the sales of aftermarket brake lines? In this internet world of spam, scam, and trolls it isn't so far fetched.

So was replacing my brake lines a good idea?
Or unnecessary overkill?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
679 Posts
:corn:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
87 Posts
2002 LTE with 57K.

Likewise I have the LT on the lift doing a 12K service and many other things as well. After installing the Speigler Lines I decide to dissect the old lines for grins and giggles.

Tough as they were to open using new utility knife blade, they are wound with double layered fiber, the inside of the lines looked good, could not detect any wear/tear. Better safe than sorry though, peace of mind.

My $0.02
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
193 Posts
I've taken the approach of "as needed". On my 2000 the front was replaced according to the records before I bought it because of a bulge in a line - sounds perfectly acceptable. I'm sure we've all owned a lot of vehicles over the years and have never replaced a brake line. I know people who have blown brake lines (and I think there are some reported on this site) on different vehicles, including my son (not in an LT).

Many on different forums say, "hey for $300 why wouldn't you upgrade your lines and never worry about it?" What are the odds or blowing one while riding? Anecdotally, I'd say less than the chance of getting struck by lightening or attacked by sharks.

Many will answer because of weight. It's SO heavy the braking power needed is extremely and puts so much extra force on the system. I'm sure they wear out quicker but inspect and replace is my motto.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26 Posts
I have 99lt Icon with 48k on her and I had the rear line to the caliper blow while riding and the line to the foot brake line start leaking after I had the plate that holds the brake petle loose checking something else. At the time I didn't know of this site and bought BMW lines or I would have went with Speiglers . I have not replaced any since but I am concerned about the front ones now should just do it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
242 Posts
I am very interested also, I have a 2000 Icon also, it still have the factory lines, or some PO replaced them with factory. I have had no issues and I look my bike over regularly. I have thought about replacing all the lines, however the one to the rear brakes seems to be the only one I hear about leaking. I am very gentle on the rear brake and often do't use it.
With the cost of $250 and being on a limited budget, there are other needs that have been more important. I am thinking about just replacing the rear with factory and just keep smiling. :)
 

·
Enjoy The Ride
Joined
·
3,981 Posts
I can't remember how many ruptured brake lines I have replaced over the years for others but it is many. The line from the foot brake is the most common to fail. Some fail from the inside.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,108 Posts
I've had four failures on my bike and did one repair for the neighbor.
Front master cylinder, rear master cylinder, rear caliper, front left caliper on my LT. Supply line between the solid ABS line and the front tee fitting for the neighbor. At least two of the failures were on lines which had never been tampered with or stressed to my knowledge.

That's not a marketing ploy, either. :histerica
 

·
Registered
The Villages, FL
Joined
·
2,601 Posts
How many people have really had brake line failures on their K1200LT...
My LT was nine years old with 92k miles when my rear brake line started leaking. This is when I changed them all out to speigler brake lines. I first thought it was the final drive leaking, but upon further inspection, it was the brake line where it had a sharp curve coming out of the caliper.
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,176 Posts
I had two OEM lines fail on my 2002 K1200LT. First was a front one and 2 years later the rear one at the master cylinder. On the front I had a visible puddle of fluid but never could find where the leak was coming from. I replaced the OEM line from the front right caliper to up in the fairing. Problem solved (after a bleed & flush). I only caught it because of the puddle but after I did it I noticed better braking. Then 2 years later my rear master cylinder line started leaking at the ferule right at the master cylinder. Again I replaced with an OEM line. The rear one I caught right away with the diminished braking and the feel in the pedal. I remember my front line was $113 and the rear was $55. I probably should've gone with Spieglers but that's hindsight.
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
Top