BMW Luxury Touring Community banner

1 - 14 of 14 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
65 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I like to plan a route, usually a mix of interstate and secondary roads. I don’t want to sit and re-program my route on my phone or GPS when I stop for gas or turn to a new road.

My GPS doesn’t accept planned routes. I like the way I can plan a route in Goggle Maps, but My Maps won’t navigate the route. I’ve tried REVER, but it’s awkward to create a route. I can’t justify the $69/yr for Tyre/My Route. MapQuest doesn’t find many of the waypoints I search for.

In this day and age of self-driving cars, it makes no sense to navigate using written notes in my tank bag. What dos other use?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
343 Posts
Garmin BaseCamp. It's free and I find it fairly easy to use to build routes and transfer them to my Nuvi 550 and Street Pilot 2730.

Rob, 2000LT
Navarre, FL
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,677 Posts
Basecamp here also.

I find Basecamp OK from ease of use perspective, but not nearly as easy to use as say Google maps. However, it interfaces to my GPSes much better. At least to my old Nav III.

I have used my Nav V for only one trip, a recent trip in the UK. Some real weirdness happened on several days of this 19 day trip, but I can't say if that was the Nav V or the Europe map I purchased for this trip. I have yet to make a domestic trip to see how that works.

I use a Rand McNally road atlas for the "strategic" phase of my planning. I then use Basecamp in conjunction with Trip Advisor for the "tactical" phase of daily route planning and selection of sights to see, lodging and restaurants at days' end. I use the Navigator itself for finding gas stations and restaurants while enroute.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
65 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
I used Basecamp on my trip to Nova Scotia last year. I used a friends GPS and was able to load my route into the GPS. The GPS model I've got doesn't support that function. Smartphones do everything a GPS can do and more, so I see the stand alone GPS going the way of the 8 track. I doesn't make sense to me to buy another one.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,677 Posts
I used Basecamp on my trip to Nova Scotia last year. I used a friends GPS and was able to load my route into the GPS. The GPS model I've got doesn't support that function. Smartphones do everything a GPS can do and more, so I see the stand alone GPS going the way of the 8 track. I doesn't make sense to me to buy another one.
My iPhone is not weather resistant and it doesn't store all of the map and other data locally like my Garmins. Nova Scotia had pretty good cell coverage, but that wasn't the case in Newfoundland and even much of mountainous PA where I live. And using cell phone data 8 hours a day gets very expensive!

Maybe some day they will be equivalent, but not yet.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
693 Posts
I tried every phone solution available and hated them all for motorcycle use. They're designed to get cages from point a to b as quickly as possible with as little traffic as possible, and that is not what I want on the bike.

I finally bought a Garmin Zumo 660 and couldn't be happier. I plan my routes on the Harley Davidson Ride Planner website, export it as a GPX file then preview/tweak it a bit in Basecamp and transfer it over to my GPS unit.

It seems a bit roundabout, but I'm not a fan of Basecamp for planning the route and if I try to dump the GPX from HD straight into the GPS it'll pick a different route between points and I'll end up going somewhere unintended.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,677 Posts
I tried every phone solution available and hated them all for motorcycle use. They're designed to get cages from point a to b as quickly as possible with as little traffic as possible, and that is not what I want on the bike.

I finally bought a Garmin Zumo 660 and couldn't be happier. I plan my routes on the Harley Davidson Ride Planner website, export it as a GPX file then preview/tweak it a bit in Basecamp and transfer it over to my GPS unit.

It seems a bit roundabout, but I'm not a fan of Basecamp for planning the route and if I try to dump the GPX from HD straight into the GPS it'll pick a different route between points and I'll end up going somewhere unintended.
Funny you mention the H-D Ride Planner. I tried several at first, including Google, Yahoo, MapQuest and others and settled on Ride a Planner for its ease of use. However, as you also found, it is completely brain dead when it comes to talking to a GPS.

When I started my first trip, I saw a straight line where I expected my route. It loaded only waypoints and, with my Nav III, put it in off-road mode so I had only straight lines. I switched to motorcycle mode and it autoroutes, but I didn't have the route I had meticulously planned.

I then did as you and tried Basecamp and once I used that a few times I abandoned Ride Planner. Basecamp has somewhat of a learning curve, but once you learn the basics it works pretty well. There was a gentleman on, I think, the BMWMOA forum or maybe ADVrider who did a nice tutorial series on Basecamp. I found that very helpful to get started. Lastly, I found that Harley seemed to abandon Ride Planner after launching it. I never saw updates or bug fixes during the time I used it.

I found the videos. Not professionally made, but I thought very useful.
http://forums.bmwmoa.org/showthread.php?74203-Learn-Garmin-BaseCamp-Tutorial-Videos
 
  • Like
Reactions: Whiskey

·
Registered
Joined
·
63 Posts
My Garmin Zumo 550 started having problems, so Garmin replaced it with a Zumo 660. The support staff told me that I could still have some issues with using Basecamp. I have been using Basecamp for over a year on many rides with specific waypoints used to take me to roads with more adventure. The support staff indicated I should use MapSource (?)(old mapping software) and import into Basecamp, and then export to the Garmin 660.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,492 Posts
Here is another free trip planner I recently discovered from a recommendation on another forum site:

Road Trip Planner | Furkot Help Center

It has a very user friendly interface and you can easily transfer your routes .gpx files directly into Nav V. I'm a very satisfied user...and I didn't have to fuss around with Basecamp.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
451 Posts
My Garmin Zumo 550 started having problems, so Garmin replaced it with a Zumo 660. The support staff told me that I could still have some issues with using Basecamp. I have been using Basecamp for over a year on many rides with specific waypoints used to take me to roads with more adventure. The support staff indicated I should use MapSource (?)(old mapping software) and import into Basecamp, and then export to the Garmin 660.
Yes Mapsource is better indicated for use with the older Garmins. It hasn't been updated in a while but should still run in Win10.
Mapsource Download
It's a bit easier to use than Basecamp. I used Basecamp with my old zumo 550 and as long as you don't use the curvy roads and stuff, it should work fine. The route profile isn't saved with the route when you send it to the device.

ps Basecamp is a PITA IMO. Furkot is interesting.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
394 Posts
Here is another free trip planner I recently discovered from a recommendation on another forum site:

Road Trip Planner | Furkot Help Center

It has a very user friendly interface and you can easily transfer your routes .gpx files directly into Nav V. I'm a very satisfied user...and I didn't have to fuss around with Basecamp.
This looks pretty good. I will try it and MotoGoLoco the next time I plan a trip. Furkot seems to be more robust than MotoGoLoco with trip planning features like hotels and motels. It looks like it is simple click and drag to create and change your route which is what I like about MotoGoLoco.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Basecamp was the hardest thing I have ever tried to use. I watched the tutorials and spent hours with it. I finally got a couple routes done.

Then, from reading this forum, I found Motogoloco and in one short evening I was making routes and down loading them to my Nav 5. It is so simple and easy to use, you will not need any introductions. Just start exploring it.

After a 900 mile 5 day trip into Wisconsin using 6 different routes, I am sold on it.
Thanks to everyone that recommended it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
63 Posts
I have been using Basecamp pretty much since it came out.
Basecamp on Windows = sucks - cumbersome - stiff.
Basecamp on Apple (Mac) = awesome and easy, Routes work now perfectly with many devices I can export many formats to many different devices GDB or GPX extensions and others.

Having used it for so long I have exported files to Goldwing systems and many Garmin devices, no clue about others never had anything but Garmin but others have successfully imported files. I have also submitted road updates to Garimin and changes when I see there is a problem and they respond and actually implement on the next release, pretty cool.

I use it to plan group rides as well as individual and post routes files and images (screen shots) as well as send them out to other group members. Also print out directions to hand out. BUt all that is Mac.

I have become used to how "close" I can get without ending up on Gravel roads and usually stay away from main roads as much as possible. Sometimes still Gravel strikes, keep going straight - turn on next road - contact Garmin let them know when I get home. Planning in Basecamp give me the option to see it in Google Earth Pro so I can fly the route I am planning and look for possible trouble spots, specially for group rides. :wave

Looked at MotoLoco - pretty cool on iPad, fast as hell to if you just look for auto routing, easy drag and drop route modification, will need to use it on the big computer to see if I can get the detail, but for general "make me a route" users - easy option.
 
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
Top