Gee whiz all my motorcycles, cars, lawnmowers have all run beautifully for miles upon miles and years upon years on E10 gasoline.
That's good to hear, and that's another set of data points.
Let me provide some others.
- In 2009, I bought a brand new 2010 Camry (SE, V-six, 268HP!). This was our daily driver, the sole car for my wife and me (and a couple of years ago we gave it to a local daughter).
That car had a diet of nothing but E10 Regular (which is what, as I mentioned earlier, all the stations sell for Regular here in my neck of the northeast). Absolutely nothing went wrong with the car -- just scheduled maintenance -- until the alternator failed at 183,000 miles (well, okay, I replaced the clouded over headlamp enclosures a few years back).
So that mirrors your experience.
- OTOH, non-daily drivers may be another matter.
As I mentioned, I don't get all excited about using E10 Regular in my bike(s), until the end of the season nears.
Perhaps you live in a more temperate climate, but my bike(s), lawn tractor, and snowblower sit unused for five or more months each year. Because ethanol blends are hygroscopic, and ethanol tends to separate out, and because of potential damage to hoses, gaskets, seals, and suchlike, I don't want it sitting idly in these machines for months on end. even with StarTron or other stabilizers. (I'm old, but not old-school enough to seasonally drain gas tanks and carburetors. It's my understanding that that sort of thing may induce its own set of problems vis-a-vis dried out seals and so forth, but I digress.)
I am not alone in this. An uncle had a mowing/landscaping business a few counties over from me, and bemoaned the destruction of his equipment brought on by any ethanol blends. The same goes for my current mowing guy, the owner of his company. (I still use my Cub Cadet to mow a portion of my lawn that lies beyond a decking bridge over a creek; his zero-turn mowers are too large to use that.)
Do your own research, certainly. Here's a snippet from a 2013 Consumer Reports article, for instance:
The Environmental Protection Agency has approved gasoline with 15 percent ethanol for use in cars year 2001 or newer, yet it prohibits its use in mowers and other power equipment, stating it may cause damage. A Department of Energy study found that E15 caused hotter operating temperatures, erratic running, and engine-part failure. But even gas with the usual 10 percent ethanol (E10) could help destroy small engines.
"Ethanol has inherent properties that can cause corrosion of metal parts, including carburetors, degradation of plastic and rubber components, harder starting, and reduced engine life," says Marv Klowak, global vice president of research and development for Briggs & Stratton, the largest manufacturer of small engines. "The higher the ethanol content, the more acute the effects." Servicing dealers are reporting similar problems, even with E10, according to the Outdoor Power Equipment Institute, the industry's trade group.
(
www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2013/03/gas-with-ethanol-can-make-small-engines-fail/index.htm)
Back in the realm of motorcycles, you might stumble across a class-action lawsuit filed against Ducati in 2010. Here's a summary:
In other words, the ethanol fuel was destroying the gas tank and making the bike inoperable. Ducati had been trying to fix the problem by simply replacing the gas tanks with identical ones that had longer warranties. But this seems (and seemed) like just a temporary solution, and enough motorcycle owners agreed that a class-action lawsuit was filed. It was reported that the ethanol fuel tank problems were so widespread that almost 300 Ducati owners had taken the time to file complaints with the National Highway Traffic & Safety Administration.
The lawsuit took a couple of years to wind its way through the courts but earlier this year, a settlement was reached where Ducati gave bike owners extended warranties and would pay for repairs to the fuel tank for tank expansion problems caused by ethanol fuels.
(
www.bellperformance.com/blog/bid/108054/motorcycle-manufacturer-gets-sued-because-of-ethanol-gas)
I think the bottom line is that not all manufacturers -- of some bikes, and many small-engined equipment -- are as diligent in their engineering and manufacture as BMW. (And of course, BMW even sometimes goes overboard with its engineering prowess -- I'm reminded of those power-assisted brakes on some bikes, awhile back.) If you're having good luck with E10 in all your equipment, fine, but apparently not everyone else is.
Our current daily driver requires Premium gas, and we mostly fill the car with the E0 Premium found at regional Stewarts stores (a chain, sort of like 7-Eleven, or Cumberland Farms, etc.). It's competitively priced, or perhaps a few cents more than we could find elsewhere, but I do this to encourage and support their selling this E0 gas (which, as I mentioned, I used to fill up my five-gallon containers for the power equipment), and I certainly have nothing against the slightly greater energy density and mileage of E0, and I like the chain, because it's employee-owned.
As I say, go ahead and do your own research, see what you feel is reliable -- or not -- information on the 'net, and come to your own conclusions.