Outbacker said:
So I asked the guy what killed the battery and he (this was a BMW dealership) asked me when I park the bike what position do I leave the key at when the bike is off. I told him I leave it at R with the ignition off and steering wheel unlocked. I leave the bike in a garage, why lock the steering wheel? He told me that is what killed to battery. The bike was not plugged into a battery tender while at GF's and the battery drained itself over the few days it was parked. I am suppose to turn the key to OFF with the steering locked as this ensures all systems are off and the battery will be fine if the bike is not plugged in for a few days.
This is how an early bike issue gets propogated and morphs into an old wive's tale.
The early LT's ('99's through maybe early '01's??) had a batch of defective radios which would not completely shut off and silently drain the battery (display would go off like it should when a properly-operating radio automatically shuts itself off after xx minutes, but the radio circuits would still be powered). BMW fixed this problem (and replaced quite a few early radios).
A dealer employee automatically espousing this as the cause of any unexplained LT battery draining is doing a disservice, as it applies a "solution" for a not-applicable problem to the wrong bike, and avoids doing the hard(er) work of figuring out what *really* caused the dead battery. There should be no reason to have to turn the key to the fork lock position on an '02 (my '02 didn't need that).
My guess -- you still have the original problem. Either (i) you have a drain or (ii) IMO, more likely, the battery is defective -- despite the fact the battery is new, examples have been known to fail within months of being put in service (usually an internal failure in one cell). The battery took a charge -- but was a *real* load test performed on it? Betcha no. One of my four LT's developed the symptoms you described within 4-5 months of purchase -- took/held a charge, usually started the bike, but sometimes the voltage was just low enough the starter relay protection circuit wouldn't let the starter relay operate. Turned out only 5 cells were on line; replaced without a moment's question by my dealer (as in, this wasn't uncommon).