In response to the question, Why did you sell your 2015 Chieftain?.
I bought an Indian Chieftain last year after several years of not riding. I narrowed my search down to the BMW R1200 GS Adventure, Honda Goldwing and the Indian Vintage. I tested all of them but the Goldwing had way too many bells and whistles and the handling seemed a little clumsy/boat-like. I wanted to look at the Indian Chieftain and Roadmaster before taking a second look at BMW. I was interested in the blue and white Chieftain, but there were none available in the Pacific Northwest. I had set up another test ride for the BMW R1200 and I had been advised by a coworker to take a look at the GTL K1600 while at the dealership. On my way to the BMW dealership, I stopped off to look at a new blue and white Chieftain in Auburn WA that I found on Craig's List the night before.
After arriving at the Indian dealership early, I was first in line and I bought the Chieftain on sight. I joined the Indian Rider's Group and had many exciting runs with this wonder group of riders. I had a great time getting my riding groove back. I also took a lot of solo rides and decided I wanted to do some long distance/cross-country rides (Alaska, California, Florida, Maine etc.) when I retired . I recently decided to retire next year and figured I should get the motorcycle situation set up for cross country touring. I checked out some touring bikes (BMW GTL, Roadmaster, Goldwing, Victory, Harley etc.) and narrowed it down to the Indian Roadmaster and BMW GTL Exclusive.
After a long test ride on the GTL, it won hands down. The handling is fantastic at any speed outside the parking lot. The technology is Star Wars (adaptive headlight, integrated anti-lock brakes, suspension, drive shaft, switchgear handlebar controls.) It is state-of-the art in all categories. By the way, this dang bike is FAST!!!. The 1600cc inline 6 is a hi-torque, hi-rpm power plant that is freaky smooth and vibration free: a totally unique riding experience.
So far, and it might be my lack of skills on the GTL, the Indian Chieftain handles better at low speeds, parking lots, parades etc. Other than that, the BMW GTL E is way better for me on long distance rides. The Indian brand is VERY popular in WA State. While the GTL is an extraordinary looking machine, I give the crowd appeal award to the Indian Chieftain. I still see an Indian bike in my future. At some point (5 years or so), I will stop taking long distance solo rides and will just do parades, rallies and show/shine stuff. I will definitely take a serious look at the 2020 Indian line up.
In summary, Indian Motorcycles seem like they are designed and built by engineers who love motorcycles. BMWs seem like they are designed and built by engineers who ride motorcycles as their only mode of transportation. http://www.bmwlt.com/forums/images/smilies/wave.gif